About Us

The Penny Candy StoreThe Penny Candy Store Massive WEB SITE is one rare candy store on the Internet where you can buy a single piece of penny candy or a box of old fashioned penny candy for the whole family. Our specialty is old fashioned penny candy; some that dates back to the late 1800’s and early 1900’s and a MEGA selection of colored candy for wedding and events. We ship nationwide at a flat shipping rate on any order, GREAT SAVING.

Bring your family and your friends with you. We have one thousand old fashioned items on display. In Our Exclusive Packages Category, you will find our uniquely packaged items, a specialty of our store. See our traditional items, like GOOD AND PLENTY® Candies , Bit O Honey, Mint Julep, Gummi Bears, Gummi Sharks, Peache Rings, Charleston Chews, Hershey’s Chocolate Bars, Sour Patch Watermelon, Sour Patch Peach and Sour Power Belts, Satellite Wafers and Boston Fruit Slices.

The Penny Candy Store has been in business for many years. Our goal is to bring to our customers the freshest superior quality old fashioned candy at affordable prices. Please, visit all of our candy departments before reaching the checkout area.

The Penny Candy StoreOUR BEST SELLERS: Old Fashioned Candy including Candy Cigarettes, Candy Necklace, Frooties, Lotsa Fizz, Airheads, Fun Dip, Sixlets, Sour Patch, Swedish Fish, Boston Fruit Slices, Satellite Wafers, Sour Belts, Nonpareils, Gummi Worms, Bulls-Eye Caramels, Neon Sour Worms, Runts,  Boston Baked Beans, Bit O’ Honey, Mary Jane & Candy Sticks.

Visit our new Retail Candy Store at 10 Merchant Street, Sharon, MA 02067

Open Daily Mon-Fri  10:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Sat 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM


Biggest Candy Store in New England, Like Us On Facebook to Follow Our Posts, Review our Pictures and Correspond with Our Social Media Team.